Two incidents in one week got me thinking about an ingredient in persuasion that we don’t often hear about.
In the first incident, an accomplished copywriter asked for feedback on a letter he intended to send to members of the local Chamber of Commerce that he’d just joined. The letter was technically excellent. It contained all the ingredients that a sales letter should have, in the right proportions and in the right places – except for one. The letter came across as cold and mechanical. The tone was distant and impersonal. Inevitably, the reader would be conscious that the writer was trying to make a sale, not trying to help out new friends and by doing so, to make a sale.
In the second incident, a woman in my copywriting training program showed me an email she sent to an entrepreneur who was looking for a ghostwriter for a collection of spiritual stories. My trainee had no ghostwriting experience and had never been published. Without any nod toward the usual credentials someone might expect in a ghostwriter, my trainee’s letter expounded on other reasons why she would be perfect for this assignment. She opened with a paragraph on the...